DAVID S. GELDMACHER, MD, Associate Professor, Department of Neurology, University of Virginia School of Medicine, Charlottesville, Va.
ELIZABETH E. O'TOOLE, MD, Acting Director, Division of Geriatric Medicine, University Hospitals of Cleveland; and Assistant Professor of Medicine
(Geriatric Medicine) and Bioethics, Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, Cleveland, Ohio.
Informal caregiving—provided mostly by family members—is a crucial component in the support of patients with Alzheimer's disease
(AD). The skills and time now required of caregivers are unprecedented in modern history because medical technology has enabled
people to live longer with chronic, progressive disease and disability. Family members and other caregivers, including those
dealing with AD patients, provide an estimated $196 to $267 billion annually in unpaid health care and homemaker services
to disabled, sick, and elderly patients. 1 Most caregivers receive no professional assistance, and they work as caregivers for an average of 20 hours per week. Many
also work paying jobs, and a significant number have been serving as informal caregivers for 5 years or more.1
Caring for an AD patient requires numerous skills, but also considerable emotional strength. Family members are typically
grieving for the ongoing loss of someone they love even as they provide care. Nearly half of caregivers for AD patients say
they have experienced depression.2 The caregiver's role will always be difficult, but primary care physicians—who often take care of both the person with AD
and the caregiver—can do much to make sure caregivers receive the education and support they need (see "Crisis points in caregiving").
When AD is first diagnosed, a meeting with immediate family members, including those who live out of town, is advised. Encourage
the family to assign one person the role of chief caregiver. Care will proceed more smoothly if everyone agrees on this primary
decision maker: The physician can deal with this person, educating him or her about the patient's physical needs, safety requirements,
potential problems, and behaviors; the primary decision-maker can then communicate with other family members regarding the
patient's care.
Caregivers need to know how to create a safe environment for the AD patient through making changes in the home. To reduce
frustration as the patient's condition deteriorates, caregivers need practical tips and training on how best to handle difficult
behaviors. They also will provide better care and be able to keep the patient at home longer if they take advantage of community
services, including respite care, day care, and support groups. Since many caregivers will experience depression, physicians
can help prevent them from becoming burned out by monitoring their emotional health and responding to problems as appropriate.
PHYSICAL AND BEHAVIORAL INTERVENTIONS
Patients with AD often are threatened by their surroundings because these seem unrecognizable. A disoriented and frightened
patient may wander, become hostile or agitated, or develop other disruptive behaviors. To help caregivers prevent these, suggest
that they make specific changes in the home and in how they interact with the patient.
Home environment
If the patient's gait is unsteady, a physical or occupational therapist can visit to evaluate the home and determine whether
safety appliances and elevated toilet seats are necessary. Even without such an assessment, the home can be equipped with
ramps and handrails. There should be ample night-time lighting in hallways and bathrooms.
Furniture should remain in place so the patient will better remember the surroundings. Familiar objects, such as old photographs,
a favorite chair, or an article of clothing, can be placed around the home; the patient's attention can be directed to these
as needed.
When possible, caregivers should eliminate busy wall decorations and flooring, replacing them with pastel colors, uncomplicated
designs, and dull finishes on wood, tile, or vinyl flooring. Mirrors are distracting, and caregivers can use translucent shades
to reduce daylight glare. These changes will create a soothing effect.
Also, provide caregivers with tips on how to prevent disorienting visual distractions. For instance, doors and handrails should
be a distinctly different color from walls so patients can identify them more easily. Many suggest that bright colors are
best. Have caregivers clear away any clutter in the home and eliminate throw rugs and extension cords or cords stretched across
a length of flooring.
Kitchen counters should be rounded to minimize injury if the patient slips and falls near them. Breakable items may be stored
out of the patient's reach. Locks can be installed on doors, and electrical outlets covered. Some patients will stuff items
into a toilet, so caregivers might consider a lock for toilets, as well.
Activities of daily living
Patients with advanced dementia often refuse to cooperate with activities such as bathing, changing clothes, or eating at
meal times. Reassure caregivers that these types of behaviors are common in those with AD and that conflict can be reduced
by being flexible with the patient's schedule. For example, the patient might not be hungry at noon or 6 PM but might be willing
to eat at other times.
Bathing
is often unpleasant or painful for patients with AD; they may resist it and sometimes become combative. Caregivers need to
know how to make the bathing experience as nonthreatening as possible. The most important strategy is for the caregiver to
remain flexible. While a bath at 7 AM might be the best time for a working caregiver, it could be the worst time for the patient's
own comfort. If the patient is more amenable to a bath in the middle of the day, perhaps the caregiver can have someone visit
the home and provide that service. Or perhaps the patient is more subdued and pliable in the evening after dinner, and the
bath could be given then. Likewise, it might be expecting too much for the patient to bathe every day, even if that was what
the patient did before AD was diagnosed. Less frequent bathing may reduce frustration while still keeping the patient adequately
clean.
Other ways the caregiver can make bathing more pleasant include these:
- Create a warm, convenient environment in advance of bathing by raising room temperature and having towels ready.
- Attend to safety issues by placing nonslip adhesives on the floor and testing the water temperature before the patient gets
into the tub.
- Turn on soothing background music that the patient likes, or offer a favorite food after the bath.
- Explain to the patient what will happen next, step by step: "I will touch your arms now," and so forth.
- Arrange for help if the patient has become physically difficult to handle during bathing, taking care to keep the patient's
dignity in mind.
- Provide sponge baths in between full baths or when the patient is strongly averse to bathing.
- Experiment with bathing times and methods to see when the patient would like to bathe and whether showering or bathing is
preferred.
- Use a washcloth to wash hair when the patient objects to getting his head wet, and be very gentle when washing the skin to
avoid skin irritation or breakdown.
Toileting
also may cause problems, and for some caregivers incontinence is a signal that the patient should be institutionalized because
care needs have become too complicated. This is an issue to discuss with caregivers before incontinence becomes a major problem.
Explain that AD patients often lose bladder or bowel control as a result of stress, medications, and other factors. They can
prevent problems by placing picture signs in the house that direct the patient to the toilet. Suggest that wastebaskets and
laundry hampers be kept out of the bathroom so that the patient will not mistake these for the toilet, and advise them to
make the toilet stand out by placing a bright cover on the seat.
Ask caregivers to monitor the patient's incontinence and identify the times when accidents occur. This will provide clues
about activities that may result in incontinence, such as too many fluids after dinner. Also, suggest that patients wear clothing
they can easily pull down to use the toilet and that caregivers offer frequent reminders to patients using familiar words.
Dressing
also poses problems for some patients. The caregiver may want to clear the patient's closet of unnecessary clothing, keeping
dress selections simple. Some AD patients prefer to dress in the same outfit each day because the clothes are familiar to
them and eliminate the need to make a decision. Caregivers can purchase two or more of the same outfit so that one can be
laundered while the patient is wearing the other.
Caregivers need to lay out clothing each day, giving the patient one piece at a time and waiting for the patient to put it
on. Clothing with simple clasps, such as hook and loop tape instead of buttons or snaps, is recommended.
Oral hygiene
needs to be monitored daily. Caregivers should encourage patients to brush their teeth after each meal. For patients who
have forgotten how to brush, caregivers can demonstrate brushing and give simple directions, such as, "Put paste on your brush."
When dementia becomes advanced, patients may no longer be able to brush their teeth at all. The family dentist may be able
to suggest devices or rinses that will be helpful.
Wandering
Wandering is one of the most difficult and common behaviors caregivers will experience with a patient with AD. Caregivers
can learn strategies to cut down daytime and nighttime wandering. In addition, they can register the patient with the Alzheimer's
Association's Safe Return program, which will help to ensure that the patient will be returned home if found by a stranger.
Ask the caregiver to describe when the patient typically wanders and what activities the caregiver was engaged in before the
wandering behavior occurred. Once these antecedents are identified, you may be able to help the caregiver eliminate factors
that promote wandering.
For example, one of the common triggers of wandering is what is sometimes called the sundown syndrome. This is triggered by
changes in lighting, so that the demented person may be unsure if it is day or evening. Dusk can be a very disorienting time,
and it may be helpful to keep the patient occupied with a quiet activity, such as folding laundry, that can be done sitting
at a table. Patients who wander in the evening may do so because of relative inactivity during the day, for example, by not
helping with household chores or engaging in normal daily activities. So when the day is over, the caregiver might be exhausted,
but the patient has stored up energy that waits to be released. The patient might even have taken naps during the day, become
bored with television, and be awake and restless at 11 PM. The caregiver can cut down this type of wandering by arranging
activities for the patient during the day. The patient can go to a day care center where activities are provided, or friends
and family can be asked to help by taking the patient to lunch or joining the patient in doing a hobby, looking at old photo
albums, or taking a walk.
Disrupted sleep patterns may lead to nighttime wandering. Patients with AD usually are older, and people typically sleep less
as they age. In addition, patients with AD might nap once or twice during the day, so their sleep requirement at night could
be as few as 4 or 5 hours. When they are not tired, they will get out of bed and wander around the house. Caregivers often
believe that sleep medication will solve this problem. You may need to explain that while a drug may help the patient fall
asleep, it will not ensure that he or she stays asleep for the entire night. A better solution would be to prevent excessive
napping and to fill the patient's day with activities. Also, suggest that caregivers eliminate caffeine in the patient's diet
by substituting decaffeinated beverages and giving the patient no liquids after 8 PM.
Agitation and other problem behaviors
Caregivers may find that the most difficult aspect of caring for a family member with AD is dealing with the patient's anger
and personality changes. These changes may trigger word or question repetition, aggressive verbal or physical behavior, suspicious
thoughts, increased anxiety and agitation, and difficulty recognizing people, places, and things.
Caregivers often take it personally when the patient lashes out at them, and you may need to explain that the behavior stems
from the disease and does not reflect how the patient feels about the family member. Follow up with tips on how to handle
the patient's agitated behavior.
One useful strategy to teach caregivers is redirection—distracting patients when they are engaged in a troublesome behavior.
This is the same technique parents of small children are adept at. For instance, a patient becomes upset when he cannot get
the television remote control to operate properly; the caregiver might respond by asking if the patient is hungry and redirecting
him to the dining room.
Emphasize for caregivers just how common behavioral problems are among persons with AD. Patients often become suspicious,
secretive, agitated, irritable, disoriented, and reluctant to change a routine or experience anything new. Changes in behavior
should not simply be dismissed, however, as signs of AD. A patient who suddenly displays increased restlessness or irritability
could have a medical problem, such as dehydration, malnutrition, infection, or blood glucose abnormalities. The behavior change
should be brought to the physician's attention. The same is true for changes in appetite and sleep. Show caregivers how problem
behaviors can result from many different causes. Then explain that it is important to investigate the cause of the behavior
problem and its potential impact before making a decision about how to respond. Some potential causes of behavior change are
illness, medication, loud noises, new places, difficulty with activities, inability to communicate, inability to recognize
the home as a familiar environment, and a busy environment (see "Coping with the AD patient's problem behavior").
Good communication techniques
 Coping with the AD patient's problem behavior
|
Misunderstandings resulting from the patient's dementia can frustrate patient and caregiver alike. Emphasize to caregivers
that when talking with the patient, they should keep it simple, using neutral tones, short phrases, and an auditory level
that the patient can clearly understand but that will not make the caregiver appear to be angry or shouting. Demented patients
might not understand all the words, but they will understand an angry tone of voice and they will respond defensively with
their own anger. Caregivers should avoid casual, "over-the-shoulder" communication, such as offhand questions or requests. Patients may not
be able to process information given in this manner and should instead be spoken to face-to-face. Patients also are easily
distractible, so caregivers should not attempt conversation in a room where the television or stereo is blaring. Explain to
caregivers that they will need to get the patient's attention and repeat the point they are trying to make until they are
certain the patient understands.
Similarly, caregivers should not ask AD patients multiple choice or fill-in-the-blank questions. It is difficult for AD patients
to weigh options and process information at the same time. To find out what the patient would like for dinner, the caregiver
can ask a Yes or No question: "Do you want fish for dinner?" If the answer is No, the caregiver can then ask, "Do you want
chicken for dinner?" When patients ask questions, caregivers should respond calmly and clearly. If necessary, the caregiver
can repeat answers and rephrase them until the patient appears to understand what is being said.
TENDING TO THE CAREGIVER'S HEALTH
Caregivers for patients with AD are prone to depression, heightened stress, physical illnesses, and frustration.2 They often feel unappreciated because patients cannot understand what they are going through—and this feeling is added to
the usual stresses of caregiving. Likewise, caregivers may become emotionally burdened and socially isolated as friends and
other family members drift away as the patient's illness progresses. Patients may live for years at home, and caregivers often
experience despair, thinking that their current situation may go on forever. These problems increase the likelihood of severe
depression and suicidal ideation.
The primary care physician may be the most important health care professional in the caregiver's life, especially when you
are physician to the caregiver as well as the person with AD. Caregivers often will not seek physical or psychological help
for themselves, so it is up to the physician to recognize when problems may be developing. Each time the caregiver brings
in the AD patient for an office visit, take the time also to assess how the caregiver is doing.
Since you cannot know what the caregiver is experiencing on a day-to-day basis, watch for subtle signs of depression and burnout
(see Table 3). Maintain eye contact with the caregiver, and casually ask how the caregiver is doing. This and follow-up questions
will provide important clues about the caregiver's emotional health. Some questions to consider include
- How are you doing?
- What are your plans for next week, the next holiday?
- Has the patient done anything unusual lately?
- Do family members come to visit you much?
- Are you taking any vitamins or medications?
- When was the last time you went out to dinner or lunch with a friend?
- When was the last time you gardened, read a book, worked on your hobby?
- Is the patient's yelling or wandering getting worse?
- What time did you go to bed last night and what time did you first wake up?
- How is your work going?
- How is your family, spouse?
- Are you experiencing any pains, headaches, or digestive problems?
- Is there anything new that you're worried about?
 TABLE 3. Signs of depression or burnout in caregivers
|
Also observe the caregiver's nonverbal presentation, such as excessive head shaking or crying during the AD patient's physical
exam. Does the caregiver appear to have lost or gained a lot of weight or seem to be excessively tired? Often the act of listening
to the caregiver will provide much-needed emotional support.
Another strategy is to ask caregivers for a recent history of the patient's behaviors and problems. This may offer clues to
the caregiver's emotional health. For example, if a caregiver begins to describe how the patient awakens at 3 AM each night
and wanders around banging doors, it becomes clear that the caregiver is not getting a full night's sleep.
If a caregiver appears to be experiencing depression or unmanageable stress, consider a prescription for an antidepressant,
if appropriate, or referral to a social worker or psychiatrist. Emphasize that the caregiver will not be able to help the
patient if the caregiver becomes sick and that everyone needs someone to talk to now and then. Caregivers may object because
of financial constraints, in which case the Alzheimer's Association may be able to recommend a local support group: The caregiver
can call their 24-hour help line (800) 272-3900 or go to http://www.alz.org on the Web. You may also want to reassure caregivers that they can always call you for assistance in the event of an emergency.
Teaching coping strategies
Explain to caregivers soon after the patient's diagnosis what cognitive and physical decline, illness, and problem behaviors
they should expect. Assist the caregiver and patient, when possible, in making decisions and plans before dementia becomes
severe. For instance, it is crucial to discuss advance directives while the patient still is able to make decisions. This
will lessen the caregiver's burden months or years down the road.
Talk with caregivers about the possibility that they may not always be able to care for the patient at home, at least not
without help. Suggest that the caregiver explore early on options such as paid help, assisted living facilities, board and
care homes, and nursing homes. The Alzheimer's Association, a social worker, or an Eldercare Locator—available at (800) 677-1116
or http://www.eldercare.gov—can be helpful in suggesting possibilities. Planning for the future and for the patient's mental decline, as well as setting
goals and seeking assistance, will help caregivers cope with the inevitable difficulties in dealing with an AD patient.
Give caregivers a list of local resources for adult day care, respite care, homemaker services, and support groups. Encourage
them to investigate some of these services since there will be times when they need assistance. For example, if a caregiver
plans to provide 24-hour, 7-day care to a spouse with AD, explain that some of these services might enable the caregiver to
attend church on Sunday mornings or buy groceries on Wednesday afternoons. Urge the caregiver to go out with friends at least
once a month and to seek help from family and friends. When a caregiver and a patient have not shown up for an office visit
in more than a year, call their home to see how they are doing. Anticipate the caregiver's needs, and make suggestions accordingly.
Soon after diagnosis, most caregivers will need some assistance with making safety and environmental changes in the home,
and this can be a good opportunity for a social worker or geriatric counselor to visit the family and make recommendations.
The social worker can provide the caregiver with emotional support and coping tips, including strategies for making sure the
patient takes medications, eats appropriately, and remains safe in the home and backyard.
This article was written by Melinda Young and updated by Dr Geldmacher.
Drs Geldmacher and O'Toole disclose no financial relationships in this area of medicine.
REFERENCES
1. Levine C, ed. Always On Call: When Illness Turns Families into Caregivers. Nashville, Tenn: Vanderbilt University Press; 2004.
2. Ziff SM, Schaffner AR: Occupational therapy student research of the needs and characteristics of dementia caregivers. In:
Perkinson MA, Braun KL, eds. Teaching Students Geriatric Research. New York, NY: The Haworth Press, Inc; 2000:29-40.
Crisis points in caregiving
If caregiver stress and burnout become concerns, have a social worker make repeated visits to the home. These professionals
can offer guidance about how to handle any new problems that have come up and be the physician’s eyes and ears, watching for
signs of substance abuse or emotional or physical neglect or abuse of the patient. Abuse sometimes occurs when a caregiver
has reached a crisis point in the care of a demented patient.
If abuse or neglect is suspected, this must be reported to state officials. The state will investigate and intervene, either
by providing additional caregiver education or by placing the patient in a long-term care facility. Physicians who do not
suspect abuse but who are concerned that a caregiver’s increasing emotional distress may lead to abuse might suggest to the
caregiver that it is time to place the patient in a nursing home or other alternative site.
Pay close attention to other signs that the caregiver has reached a breaking point. One sign is that the patient has become
physically violent, striking out at the caregiver. The caregiver might be reluctant to report this, but if the caregiver has
visible bruises, ask if the patient has become violent.
Another common breaking point for caregivers is when the patient becomes incontinent. Fecal incontinence is es-pecially difficult
to deal with. For some families, it might be enough to give the caregiver information on how to set up a toileting schedule
and how to watch for signs of skin breakdown, with follow-up by a home health nurse. But do not assume that all families will
be able to cope with incontinence, even with additional help and education. Some will be incapable of providing adequate care
in this circumstance, making placement in a nursing home or other alternative care facility in the patient’s best interest.
Primary care physicians are well placed to watch for crises among AD patients and their families and to refer them to support
and other medical services whenever necessary. Probably the most important referral you can make is to the Alzheimer’s Association
http://www.alz.org